Trump's Potential Treasury Secretary Headed A 'Foreclosure Machine'

Nov 29, 2016
Originally published on November 30, 2016 9:14 am

After campaigning with lots of populist and anti-Wall Street rhetoric, Donald Trump is seriously considering a veteran Wall Street financier, Steve Mnuchin, to be his Treasury secretary.

Mnuchin spent 17 years at Goldman Sachs, ultimately as a partner at the investment bank. More recently, he's headed a privately owned hedge fund, Dune Capital Management. Last April he became Trump's chief fundraiser, and he's now a member of the president-elect's transition team.

But Mnuchin's resume also includes a stint as chairman and CEO of a California bank that's been called a foreclosure machine.

During the depths of the financial crisis, Mnuchin was looking to make profits from the ruins of the housing bust. In 2009, he put together a group of billionaire investors and bought a failed California-based bank, IndyMac. It had been taken over by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. after its sketchy mortgage loans went bad.

Mnuchin and his partners bought IndyMac on the condition that the FDIC agree to pay future losses above a certain threshold. They renamed the bank OneWest Bank and, after running it for six years, they sold it last year for a profit, estimated at close to $1.5 billion.

Kevin Stein of the California Reinvestment Coalition, a housing advocacy group, says that profit was made on the backs of suffering California homeowners. "In essence what they did is they bought a foreclosure machine," he says.

According to the coalition, OneWest foreclosed on more than 36,000 homeowners under Mnuchin. During that time, the FDIC made payments to OneWest totaling more $1 billion. Those payments went to the "billionaire investors of OneWest Bank," says Stein, "to cover the cost of foreclosing on working-class, everyday, American folks," many of whom lived in California.

Rex Schaffer, 86, and his wife Rose were among those who lost their homes, in a OneWest foreclosure. After living nearly 50 years in their home in La Puente, Calif., the Schaffers took a home equity loan but struggled to make the payments. They say they qualified three times for a government assisted modification, but OneWest failed to modify the loan.

"It was a disaster dealing with those people," Rex Shaffer says. "We'd have a different person every time we called in." He counted 33 OneWest employees, in all, and each one would give him "a different story."

Facing threats that their home would be auctioned off, the Schaffers finally got through to a OneWest vice president. According to Rex Shaffer, the VP said, "I'm going to get you a 60-day extension on the sale date, so we can work this thing out." That was on Feb. 17, 2011. But the next day, the Schaffers' house was sold without their knowledge. "We didn't even know it — didn't have the faintest idea," Rex Shaffer says.

They voted for Donald Trump, but Rose Schaffer says they're praying he doesn't choose Mnuchin as his Treasury secretary. "If he can't run his own little bank," she asks, "how can he handle a large thing for the United States?"

Millions of Americans were foreclosed on after the financial crisis; some were duped by real estate agents and bankers, others took imprudent risks.

It is important to note that Mnuchin and his partners bought a bank from the government that was already in trouble because of bad loans. But Stein, of the California Reinvestment Coalition, argues that Trump's message was that his presidency would rescue working families and the forgotten middle class. Stein says Mnuchin's actions run counter to the message.

"Mr. Mnuchin oversaw a bank that created difficulties and financial ruin for tens of thousands of families," Stein says. Stein and his organization have also charged that, under Mnuchin, OneWest illegally avoided serving minority communities in California.

Despite NPR's repeated requests for comment, Mnuchin did not provide a response.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

When Donald Trump was running for president, he campaigned as a populist. In places like Iowa, he attacked Wall Street. He said he would not let it get away with murder and that it had caused tremendous problems. Now multiple news outlets are reporting that Wall Street financier Steve Mnuchin is Donald Trump's pick Treasury secretary. Mnuchin's resume also includes a stint as chairman and CEO of a California bank that has been called a foreclosure machine. NPR's John Ydstie reports.

JOHN YDSTIE, BYLINE: Steve Mnuchin spent 17 years at Goldman Sachs, ultimately as a partner. And more recently, he's headed a privately owned hedge fund, Dune Capital Management. Last April, he became Trump's chief fundraiser, and now he's a member of the president-elect's transition team. But during the depths of the financial crisis, Mnuchin was working to make profits from the ruins of the housing bust.

In 2009, he put together a group of billionaire investors and bought a failed California-based bank, IndyMac. It had been taken over by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation after its sketchy mortgage loans went bad. Mnuchin and his partners bought IndyMac on the condition that the FDIC agree to pay future losses above a certain threshold. They renamed the bank OneWest, and after running it for six years, they sold it last year for a nice profit estimated at close to one and a half billion dollars.

Kevin Stein of the California Reinvestment Coalition, a housing advocacy group, says that profit was made on the backs of suffering California homeowners.

KEVIN STEIN: In essence, what they did is they bought a foreclosure machine.

YDSTIE: Stein says OneWest foreclosed on more than 36,000 homeowners under Mnuchin. And during that time, the FDIC made payments to the bank totaling more than a billion dollars.

STEIN: These are payments that are going to the billionaire investors of OneWest Bank to cover the cost of foreclosing on, you know, working-class, everyday, American folks, many of them in California.

YDSTIE: Including 86-year-old Rex Schaffer and his wife, Rose, who lost their home in a OneWest foreclosure.

REX SCHAFFER: It was a disaster dealing with those people.

YDSTIE: After nearly 50 years in their home in La Puente, Calif., the Schaffers took an equity loan but struggled to make the payments. They say they qualified three times for a government-assisted modification, but OneWest failed to modify the loan.

REX SCHAFFER: We'd have a different person every time we called in, and there's a different story.

YDSTIE: Facing threats that their home would be auctioned off, the Schaffers finally got through to a OneWest vice president.

REX SCHAFFER: And he says, I'm going to get you a 60-day extension on the sale date so we can work this thing out. Well, that was on February 17, 2011. And on February 18, that house was auctioned off. We didn't even know it, and didn't have the faintest idea.

YDSTIE: They voted for Donald Trump, but Rose Schaffer says they're praying he doesn't choose Mnuchin as his Treasury secretary.

ROSE SCHAFFER: If he can't run his own little bank, how can he handle a large thing for United States?

YDSTIE: Millions of Americans were foreclosed on after the financial crisis. Some were duped by realtors and bankers. Others took imprudent risks. It is important to note that Steve Mnuchin and his partners bought a bank from the government that was already in trouble because of bad loans. But Kevin Stein argues Donald Trump's message was that his presidency would rescue working families in the forgotten middle class. He says Mnuchin's actions run counter to that message.

STEIN: Mr. Mnuchin oversaw a bank that created difficulties and financial ruin for tens of thousands of families.

YDSTIE: Stein and his organization have also charged that under Mnuchin, OneWest illegally avoided serving minority communities in California. Despite repeated requests for comment, Mnuchin did not provide a response. John Ydstie, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.