Around the Nation
5:50 pm
Thu November 7, 2013

Trim Recess? Some Schools Hold On To Child's Play

Originally published on Thu November 7, 2013 6:51 pm

It's recess time at Ruby Bridges Elementary School and a third-grader is pummeling a plastic tetherball with focused intensity. He's playing at one of more than a half-dozen recess play stations on the school's sprawling cement playground — there's also wall ball, basketball, capture the flag, sharks and minnows, a jungle gym and tag.

The kids at this school in Alameda, Calif., a city on a small island near Oakland, get recess-time help from coach Kenny Wong. Wong is an employee with Playworks, a nonprofit that works with low-income area schools in California and across the country.

A growing body of research shows that play is fundamental to kids' development by promoting social interaction, exploration and creativity. There are no recent national studies or fresh numbers on recess time, but 2005 data from the Education Department survey and a 2006 report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention show that about 9 in 10 elementary schools regularly schedule recess, with times ranging from 24 to 30 minutes a day.

Still, many districts report that they are under continued pressure to add instructional time to the day — and recess minutes are often the first place administrators look.

Educating 'The Whole Child'

But some schools, many with help from Playworks, are pushing back against those cuts.

At Ruby Bridges, Wong is organizing a freewheeling, high-energy game of tag called "everyone's it." It's fun, but it's also a way to get kids moving without making them run laps.

"There's a lot of running involved," Wong explains. "During stretches or running laps, kids will just hate running laps. But once the game starts, they'll just go nonstop."

California mandates 400 minutes of recess a month, but Ruby Bridges has embraced expanded recess. Principal Jan Goodman says it's an important tool to help promote a healthy lifestyle and help kids stay focused in class.

School districts that are cutting back on recess or physical education to save money or add instruction time should think twice, Goodman says. "It's penny wise and pound foolish to cut back recess and put in academic time. Because, in the end, the kids won't be prepared for academic time.

"It's totally important for me to educate the whole child, and the body is part of the whole child," Goodman adds. "And that's what Playworks does: teaches you to work as a team and not always be concerned with winning."

Goodman says the Playworks program and coach have also helped to reduce playground conflicts through old-school games. When disputes break out, Wong and teachers promote rock, paper scissors to resolve them.

Jackie Hemann, Playwork's East San Francisco Bay program director, says the coaches "create a physically and emotionally safe environment for kids to just be kids. That means trying new things. If they fail, it's OK. It's a setting where they're not going to be made fun of for trying new things, and there will be a lot of praise when they do succeed."

Helping To Close A Recess Gap

While some schools are shortening recess time, Playworks and other groups also report that kids in areas of concentrated poverty and low-income neighborhoods are far more likely to see cuts in recess time than schools in wealthier districts and are also more likely to have no recess at all.

About 70 percent of Ruby Bridge's 600 students qualify for free or reduced lunch. Some come from Alameda Point, one of the five poorest neighborhoods in the Bay Area.

Barry Savin, who teaches fourth and fifth grade here, says some of the kids don't have a safe and secure place to play outside back in their neighborhoods. And some parents might not emphasize outdoor play time after school, he adds.

The Playworks program, he says, has been a huge boost. "It allows them to have a structured place in which they can go play games and have fun. A lot of the stress is on teamwork and cooperation, and hopefully those things will carry on."

Savin and other teachers work with the Playworks coach to encourage every child, including kids with physical challenges, to take part in some kind of semi-structured game at recess.

Wong has also trained some three dozen kids across the school to serve as "junior coaches," who help organize games, resolve conflicts and clean up. And while one third-grader says he enjoys junior coaching because he gets to leave class two minutes early, another says it lets the kids "have a little bit of fun after finishing our work. And we have to finish our work so we can do junior coach duty."

The school helps pay for part of the program, which costs about $30,000 per year, with federal school money targeting low-income areas.

Even those who support Playworks lament the fact that the program has to exist at all. It's a sad testament, one teacher says, to how some schools and neighborhoods have de-emphasized play and recess, just as kids ramp up screen time on tablets and smartphones.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

A growing body of research shows that play is fundamental to children's development. It promotes social interaction, exploration, creativity, yet schools across the country have been reducing the amount of time kids get for recess. Now, some schools are pushing back and they're getting help from a nonprofit organization that works with children in low income areas.

As NPR's Eric Westervelt reports, these schools are embracing play time as a key part of the learning process.

ERIC WESTERVELT, BYLINE: A third grade boy with faux-hawk, a spiky hair gel created Mohawk pummels a plastic tetherball with focused intensity. It's recess at Ruby Bridges Elementary School in Alameda, a city on a small island next to Oakland, California.

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD: Hey, you cheated...

WESTERVELT: Tetherball is just one of more than half a dozen recess play stations on the school's sprawling cement playground. There's also wall ball, basketball, capture the flag, sharks and minnows, a jungle gym, and several games of tag. Before the tag whistle blows, some second graders reach for the microphone.

HEATHER BENJAMIN: My name is Heather Benjamin and I'm popular.

RAHEL: Hi, my name I'm Rahel.

WESTERVELT: You're on the radio.

RAHEL: Yay, I'm on the radio.

(LAUGHTER)

WESTERVELT: The children get recess time help from Coach Kenny Wong, who's with the non-profit group Playworks, which works with low income area schools in California and across the U.S. Kenny's organizing a freewheeling, high-energy game of tag called Everyone's It.

KENNY WONG: And there's a lot of running involved, which during, like, stretches or running laps, kids will just hate running laps. But once the game starts, like, they'll just go non-stop.

WESTERVELT: It's a way to get them to run without telling them it's run time?

WONG: Right.

WESTERVELT: Ruby Bridges Elementary has embraced expanded recess, going beyond California's mandate of 400 minutes a month, as an important tool to help promote a healthy lifestyle and to help kids focus back in class, says Principal Jan Goodman.

JAN GOODMAN: It's totally important for me to educate the whole child and the body is part of the child. And that's what Playworks does: teaches you to work as a team and not always be concerned with winning. So send the whole Congress to Playworks, and maybe the budget wouldn't be stalled.

WESTERVELT: Goodman says the Playworks coach and program have also helped reduce playground conflicts through old-school games. When a dispute breaks out, Coach Kenny and the teachers first try to promote rock, paper scissors to resolve it.

WONG: What beats rock?

UNIDENTIFIED CHILDREN: Scissors.

WONG: What beats rock?

UNIDENTIFIED CHILDREN: Paper.

WONG: What beats paper?

UNIDENTIFIED CHILDREN: Scissors.

WESTERVELT: About 70 percent of Ruby Bridge's 600 students qualify for free or reduced lunch. Some come from Alameda Point, one of the five poorest neighborhoods in the Bay Area.

Fourth and fifth grade teacher Barry Savin says some of kids don't have a totally safe and secure place to play outside back in their neighborhoods. In addition, parents might not emphasize outdoor playtime after school. He says the Playworks program has been a huge boost.

BARRY SAVIN: It allows them to have a structured place in which they can go play games and have fun. A lot of the stress is on teamwork and cooperation, and hopefully those things will carry on.

Everybody line up...

WESTERVELT: Savin and other teachers work with the Playworks coach to encourage every child, including any physically challenged kids, to take part in some kind of semi-structured game at recess. And Coach Kenny has trained some three dozen kids across the school to serve as junior coaches to take a leadership role. They help organize, resolve conflicts and clean up.

I ask third grade Junior Coaches Isaaic(ph), Nada, Nicholas, and Mohammed about their jobs.

ISSAIC: It's a big responsibility.

WESTERVELT: Why is recess for you guys important?

NADA: Because we get to leave two minutes early from our class, and we...

NICHOLAS: That's not the reason because we get a break. We get to have a little bit of fun after finishing our work. And we have to finish our work so we can do doing junior coach...

MOHAMMED: We have assembly.

WESTERVELT: Alright. Thanks, guys. You got assembly,

(LAUGHTER)

WESTERVELT: ...you got to go.

The school helps partially pay for the program, which costs about $30,000 a year with federal school money targeting low income areas. One educator who supports the program said the very fact that Playworks exists is a sad testament to how some schools and neighborhoods have de-emphasized play and recess, as kids ramp up screen time on tablets and smartphones.

WONG: Boys and girls, spread out and listen for the whistle.

(SOUNDBITE OF A WHISTLE)

WESTERVELT: Eric Westervelt, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.